Change in Management Based on Pathologic Second Opinion among Bladder Cancer Patients Presenting to a Comprehensive Cancer Center: Implications for Clinical Practice

INTRODUCTION - To evaluate the incidence and degree of change from a pathologic second opinion of bladder biopsies at a Comprehensive Cancer Center that were initially performed at referring community hospitals. The secondary objective was to determine the impact the potential changes would have on a patient's treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS - Dedicated genito-urinary pathologists reviewed 1,191 transurethral biopsies of the bladder and/or prostatic urethra from 2008-2013. Major and minor treatment changes were defined as altering recommendations for cystectomy, systemic chemotherapy, or primary cancer diagnosis and alterations in intravesical regimens, respectively.

RESULTS - There were 326/1191 patients (27.4%) with a pathologic change on second opinion: grade (62/1191, 5.2%), stage (115/1191, 9.7%), muscle in the specimen (29/1191, 2.4%), presence or absence of Carcinoma-in-Situ (34/1191, 2.9%). Outside pathology did not address the presence or absence of lymphovascular invasion (LVI) in 620/759(81.7%) of invasive cases (>cT1), of which, 35/620(5.6%) had LVI. There were 212 mixed, variant, or nonurothelial histologies detected in 199/1191(16.7%) patients with 114/212(53.7%) resulting in reclassification by our pathologists. Potential treatment alterations accounted for 182/1191(15.3%) of cases with 141/1191(11.8%) imparting major changes. There were 82/1191(6.8%) changes in recommendation for a radical cystectomy, 38/1191(3.2%) had a complete change in primary tumor type and 21/1191(1.8%) for change in chemotherapy regimen.

CONCLUSIONS - The amount and degree of pathologic changes and its potential impact on treatment emphasizes the importance of bladder cancer patients having their histology reviewed by genito-urinary dedicated pathologists. In our cohort, 15.3% of patients could see a treatment alteration, with 11.8% being a major change.

Urology. 2016 Mar 31 [Epub ahead of print]

Adam M Luchey, Neil J Manimala, Shohreh Dickinson, Jasreman Dhillon, Gautum Agarwal, Jorge L Lockhart, Philippe E Spiess, Wade J Sexton, Julio M Pow-Sang, Scott M Gilbert, Michael A Poch


Newsletter subscription

Free Daily and Weekly newsletters offered by content of interest

The fields of GU Oncology and Urology are rapidly advancing. Sign up today for articles, videos, conference highlights and abstracts from peer-review publications by disease and condition delivered to your inbox and read on the go.