| BJUI Mini Reviews - Non-Surgical Management of Multicystic Dysplastic Kidney |
|
|
|
|
|
| Friday, 11 April 2008 | |
|
(BJUI Mini Reviews) - Objective: To better define the outcome and association of multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) with hypertension, vesico-ureteric reflux (VUR), infection and cancer, as there is no consensus on the management of patients born with MCDK.
More BJUI Mini Reviews and Archives on UroToday.com Please log-in or register in order to submit comments. Powered by AkoComment! |
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
|
UroToday, 1802 Fifth Street, Berkeley CA 94710 510.540.0930 (fax), info@urotoday.com ISSN 1939-4810
Privacy Policy | © 2008 UroToday ® All Rights Reserved |








![2008 BJU INTERNATIONAL | 101, 804–808 | doi:10.1111/j.1464-410X.2007.07328.x
Non-surgical management of multicystic
dysplastic kidney
Angelo J. Cambio, Christopher P. Evans and Eric A. Kurzrock
Department of Urology, University of California, Davis School of Medicine, Sacramento, CA, USA
Accepted for publication 7 September 2007
RESULTS
The inclusion criteria were met by 105
reports that were subsequently analysed.
Of MCDK, 60% regress or involute within
3 years. About 25% of patients will have
VUR into the contralateral kidney, of
which 90% is grade
≤
3. The risk of
urinary tract infection appears to be
associated with VUR or coexistent
abnormalities rather than the MCDK.
The risk of hypertension is no greater
than that in the general population and
nephrectomy is usually not curative.
The overall risk of Wilms’ tumour
developing in a MCDK is
<
1 in 2000. All
reported Wilms’ tumours were identified
before 4 years of age and 70% presented
as a palpable mass.
CONCLUSIONS
Published reports support the non-surgical
management of MCDK. Common practice has
been to remove palpable or growing MCDKs,
although these represent a very small fraction
of MCDKs. In theory, ultrasonographic
surveillance until 4 years old might allow the
earlier detection of a Wilms’ tumour, and
decrease the intensity of chemotherapy and
improve prognosis. Previous reports do not
prove or disprove this concept, and the
appropriate frequency of surveillance is not
evident.
KEYWORDS
multicystic dysplastic kidney, Wilms’ tumour,
renal cell carcinoma, vesico-ureteric reflux
OBJECTIVES
To better define the outcome and association
of multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) with
hypertension, vesico-ureteric reflux (VUR),
infection and cancer, as there is no consensus
on the management of patients born with
MCDK. The risk of cancer has dictated the
surgical management of the disease in
the past.
METHODS
The Medline database was searched for
articles published between 1965 and 2006
and written in the English language, and
containing the keywords ‘multicystic
dysplastic kidney’.
INTRODUCTION
The incidence of multicystic dysplastic kidney
(MCDK) is not well defined; it is reported to
occur unilaterally in one in 2400, one in 4100
or one in 4300 live births, and is the most
common form of cystic kidney in children
[1,2]. The condition occurs more commonly in
males than females (2.4:1) but females are
twice as likely to have bilateral MCDK. The left
The incidence of multicystic dysplastic kidney
(MCDK) is not well defined; it is reported to
occur unilaterally in one in 2400, one in 4100
or one in 4300 live births, and is the most
common form of cystic kidney in children
[1,2]. The condition occurs more commonly in
males than females (2.4:1) but females are
twice as likely to have bilateral MCDK. The left
kidney is more often affected than the right.
MCDK has two subtypes that are based
on gross appearance, i.e. solid cystic
dysplasia and hydronephrotic form. The
former is characterized by increased
stromal components and smaller
cysts; the hydronephrotic form of MCDK is
characterized by an identifiable renal pelvis.
Differentiating MCDK from Wilms’ tumour or
RCC with cystic components is a challenge
and a potential source of error in reporting
neoplasia associated with MCDK [3].
Recent reports support non-surgical
management, with long-term follow-up
[1,4], and there is no strong evidence
supporting any particular follow-up regimen.
Current non-surgical management protocols
might include renal ultrasonography (US),
growth-chart analysis, urine analysis, blood
tests and blood pressure assessment, all of
which are at variable and arbitrary intervals.
The morbidity and cost of surgery have
been compared to the morbidity, cost,
inconvenience and bother of an extended
follow-up; however, no universally accepted
management protocol has emerged. After a
thorough review of published reports in the
English language, our goal was to present a
concise statement on the risks and discuss
management options.
METHODS
The Medline database was searched for
articles published between 1965 and 2006 in
the English language and containing the
keywords ‘multicystic dysplastic kidney’. Case
reports were excluded unless they involved
cancer. The abstracts of 152 articles were
analysed and of these, 105 reports were
reviewed. If an article cited relevant
original work in report before 1965,
these were also analysed. We specifically
assessed the relationship of MCDK with VUR,
UTI, hypertension, cancer and the need for
surgery.
RESULTS
DIAGNOSIS
Previous reports show that historically MCDK
was a rare finding that was diagnosed by a
palpable abdominal mass and managed
with nephrectomy [5]. The widespread
use of antenatal US has led to an increasing
incidence of MCDK [6,7]. Antenatal US has a
sensitivity of 80–100% with a false-positive
rate of
≈
2%, the main differential diagnosis
being a poorly functioning hydronephrotic
kidney [8,9].
Abnormal postnatal US verifies the suspicious
finding (Fig. 1). A renal isotope scan is useful
NON-SURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF MULTICYSTIC DYSPLASTIC KIDNEY
©
2008 THE AUTHORS
JOURNAL COMPILATION
©
2008 BJU INTERNATIONAL
805
when the MCDK is not easily distinguished
from a hydronephrotic kidney. A renal
concentration of isotope is indicative of
hydronephrosis, as renal function in MCDK is
exceedingly rare. If necessary, a DMSA scan is
appropriate as a diuretic/excretory evaluation
is unnecessary.
VUR
Numerous articles included voiding cysto-
urethrography (VCUG) in the evaluation of
MCDK. VUR was reported to occur into the
contralateral kidney in 15–28% of patients
[10–14]. Miller
et al.
[12] retrospectively
investigated the fate of the refluxing
contralateral kidney in 75 children with
MCDK; VUR was diagnosed in 25% of
patients, with grade distributed as 5% for I,
42% for II, 42% for III, 11% for IV and none of
grade V. There was spontaneous resolution
within 5 years in most (89%) of the patients
with grade I and II VUR, and half of patients
with grades III or IV VUR. Of children in this
series, 19% had a documented UTI at some
point during the follow-up (median
53 months). The presence of VUR did not
correlate with the growth of the normal
kidney in a child on antimicrobial prophylaxis.
In 2005, Ismaili
et al.
[11] challenged the
routine use of VCUG to detect contralateral
VUR in patients with a MCDK. In a
retrospective analysis they reported that two
successive normal neonatal renal US might
exclude significant contralateral anomalies,
thus avoiding VCUG and its associated
radiation exposure and pain. The sensitivity,
specificity, positive and negative predictive
value of two successive neonatal
ultrasonograms to detect VUR was 75%, 95%,
80% and 93%, respectively. All patients with
high-grade VUR were detected by US. Ismaili
et al.
recommended that VCUG not be used
in those patients who have two normal
contralateral postnatal renal ultrasonograms.
The rate of UTI, with or without antibiotics,
was not reported, and is a major limitation of
the study.
INVOLUTION
The fate of the affected kidney is variable;
affected kidneys involute or decrease in size
in 60–89% of cases, some stay the same
(2–37%) and few increase in size (0–18%)
[13,15,16]. The timeline to involution is
variable; the mean time was reported as
20 months in one study [13] and 122 months
in another [16]. Statistically derived estimates
show that 20% and 50% of MCDKs will
become undetectable by US (involution) at 3
and 5 years of follow-up, respectively [17].
HYPERTENSION
Hypertension associated with MCDK has been
anecdotally reported; the true incidence is
unknown, but thought to be extremely low. In
a systematic review of 29 studies, including
1115 patients, Narchi [18] recently reported
the incidence of hypertension associated with
MCDK as 5.4 per 1000 patients. Surprisingly,
this is lower than the incidence of
hypertension in the general paediatric
population. However, Narchi caution that
their comparison of series was hampered by
disparities in patient age, follow-up and
criteria for defining hypertension. In another
large study, Wacksman and Phipps [19] found
no cases of hypertension in a series of 441
cases reported to the Multicystic Kidney
Registry. Hypertension in a patient with MCDK
might be an indication for nephrectomy, but
in about two-thirds of cases the hypertension
will persist after nephrectomy [20].
WILMS’ TUMOUR (WT)
There were reports on the association of WT
with MCDK, primarily based on case studies
and small series (Table 1 [21–28]). Evidence
supporting these case reports is often
incomplete and not supported by outside
pathological review [3]. Despite the nature of
this evidence, the purported increased risk of
cancer continues to dictate the management
of MCDK for many urologists. Many patients
have had and continue to have nephrectomies
[29].
In response to this issue, Beckwith [3]
calculated the risk of WT in MCDK, based on
work by Gordon
et al.
[2], in which 10
unilateral cases of MCDK were detected in
43 175 live births, thereby estimating an
incidence of 1 in 4300 live births. The National
Wilms’ Tumor Study Pathology Center
provided data on 7500 WTs collected over
26 years; only five of the 7500 WTs occurred
in a MCDK. The risk of WT in the general
population is 1 in 8000–10 000. Taking into
account the risk of MCDK during the same
26-year period, the calculated risk of WT in
association with MCDK is 1 in 2000. With a
90% cure rate for WT, Beckwith concluded
that nephrectomy and routine monitoring are
not justified [3].
Surprisingly, through a completely different
approach, Noe
et al.
[30] had previously
calculated that 2000 nephrectomies would be
necessary to prevent one WT. Nephrogenic
rests are a precursor to WT and the incidence
is
≈
1% in the general population, or
≈
100
times the incidence of WT. The incidence of
nephrogenic rests in those with WT is higher,
at 12–40% [31], and in those with MCDK is
reported to be to 3–5% [31]. Assuming 1% of
cases of nephrogenic rests degenerate to WT
[31] and there is a 5% increased risk of
nephrogenic rests with MCDK, 2000
nephrectomies would be needed to prevent
one WT [30]. The calculation by Noe
et al.
supports the estimate generated by
Beckwith [3].
In the Preliminary Report of the Multicystic
Kidney Registry, Wacksman and Phipps [19]
report only two cases of WT in the 25 years
before their 1993 publication. A 10-month-
old and 4-year-old both presented with a
palpable mass. Of the 260 cases of MCDK in
the registry that were managed without
surgery, there were no cases of WT. The
Multicystic Kidney Registry stopped enrolling
patients in the late 1990s, but only one
patient in
≈
900 cases registered developed a
malignancy, and this malignancy did not
develop in a true MCDK (J Wacksman,
personal communication 2006). Wacksman
and Phipps [19] estimate that 8000 MCDKs
would have to be removed to prevent one
tumour.
In a systematic review of 26 studies including
1041 patients, Narchi [32] reported that there
were no WTs in patients with MCDK. While
the results from this systematic review
are promising, the author noted that the
study was limited by heterogeneity of the
populations, an 18-year span of studies and
availability/accuracy of antenatal US, the
varied duration of follow-up and varied
FIG. 1.
An ultrasonogram of a MCDK.
CAMBIO
ET AL.
©
2008 THE AUTHORS
806
JOURNAL COMPILATION
©
2008 BJU INTERNATIONAL
frequency of US surveillance. Nevertheless,
there is no large review or meta-analysis
reporting an association of MCDK with WT.
In our review of 10 reported cases of WT
associated with a purported MCDK (Table 1),
seven presented with a palpable abdominal
mass. No patient with documented WT
presented after 4 years of age; only four had a
known history of MCDK, and none presented
with metastatic disease. Survival data were
available for eight of the 10 cases. The follow-
up ranged from 7 months to 12 years and no
recurrences or deaths were reported. There
were no reports of WT associated with an
involuted kidney.
RCC
We found six reports of RCC associated with
MCDK in patients aged 15–44 years; all cases
were of advanced stage with large tumours.
The accuracy of the pathological diagnosis of
MCDK with these large tumours is debatable.
None were subject to outside pathological
review, as with WT. None of the patients had a
pre-existing history of MCDK. As such, it is
possible that some of these were cystic RCCs.
DISCUSSION
Before antenatal US was routinely used
most identified MCDKs were large and
palpable. This abnormal finding on physical
examination led to the preferred treatment of
nephrectomy. In the era of antenatal US the
prevalence of MCDK has increased and the
size of affected kidneys has decreased [5].
High rates of spontaneous partial or complete
involution [1,13,15–17] and low rates of
hypertension [18] and neoplasia [32] have
shifted the management to a non-surgical
approach.
There is little controversy about the diagnostic
evaluation of MCDK. The argument for
VCUG in patients with MCDK parallels the
controversy and rhetoric about infants with
pre- and postnatal mild hydronephrosis; VUR
is found in 15–40% of these infants [33].
Evidence suggests that the finding of low-
grade VUR might not be clinically important
[33]. Unlike infants with prenatal
hydronephrosis, children with MCKD have
half the renal reserve. The recognition of
reflux and prevention of pyelonephritis in
children with a solitary functioning kidney is
important. Cystography is still practised
routinely, as reported in the vast majority of
published series.
Some authors include urine culture and blood
pressure assessment as components of the
follow-up for MCDK. Urine culture in children
carries an inherent rate of false-positive
results. The preliminary report of the
Multicystic Registry reported only 12 cases of
UTI in the 260 cases that were managed
without surgery [19]. Similar to the
management of VUR, routine urine culture in
asymptomatic children is hampered by a
significant false-positive rate, which negates
its value. Paediatricians recommend blood
pressure monitoring in all children during
clinical encounters after the age of 3 years.
Children aged
<
3 years should have their
blood pressure measured under special
circumstances, such as MCDK [34].
Complete involution, meaning that the MCDK
has become imperceptible to US, is a
satisfying outcome. However, the malignant
potential of even small amounts of residual
tissue is uncertain. In our review we were
unable to find one case of WT associated with
an involuted MCDK. All cases of WT presented
before 4 years old and at least seven of the 10
were palpable. These are new findings from
our review. No deaths from WT were reported.
Two investigators, with different methods,
have calculated the risk of developing a WT to
be 1 in 2000 for children with MCDK (the risk
in the general paediatric population is 1 in
8–10 000).
An estimated 36 000 new cases of RCC were
diagnosed in the USA in 2005. Considering
the higher incidence of RCC in men and the
higher incidence of MCDK in newborn boys,
there should be
≈
10 random associations of
RCC with MCDK per year. As there are only six
reported in the English language, MCDK
TABLE 1
Case reports of Wilms’ tumour associated with MCDK
Reference
Age*,
months/sex Presentation Outcome
[21] 18/M Prenatal US showing renal cysts; L flank mass on physical exam; confirmed by
postnatal US; 14 months persistent cystic disease with no evidence of tumour;
4 months later parent noticed increasing abdominal girth; 16
×
10
×
13 cm solid
tumour with calcifications; L total nephrectomy; favourable histology WT with
invasion into perirenal fat
Chemo for 6 months NED 13 month f/u
[22] 11/M Prenatal diagnosis MCDK, lost to f/u, 11 months presented with abdominal mass Positive response to chemo f/u NR
[23] 5/F Prenatal diagnosis of MCDK, abdominal swelling NED 6 year f/u
3/F L flank mass on US Chemo; NED 8 year f/u
[24] 17/M MCDK discovered on MRI when evaluating anorectal malformation NR
[25] 5/NR Nephrectomy for abnormal sonogram NED, 1 year f/u
[26] 48/F Palpable abdominal mass NR
[27] 10/M Palpable abdominal mass NED, 11 year f/u
[28] 9/F Palpable abdominal mass NED, 5 year f/u
1/M Palpable abdominal mass NED, 5 month f/u
f/u, follow-up; L, left, NED, no evidence of disease; NR, not reported; chemo, chemotherapy. *Age at diagnosis of growing abdominal mass that prompted surgical
intervention.
NON-SURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF MULTICYSTIC DYSPLASTIC KIDNEY
©
2008 THE AUTHORS
JOURNAL COMPILATION
©
2008 BJU INTERNATIONAL
807
might carry an equal or lesser risk of
developing RCC than a normal kidney.
In urological reports, proponents of surgery
argue that non-surgical management
requires a long-term follow-up with frequent,
costly US, leaving patients at risk of infection,
hypertension and cancer, especially in those
cases lost to follow-up. A few studies showed
that early nephrectomy is more cost-effective
than non-surgical follow-up. These types
of analyses are arbitrary, as the necessary
frequency of US surveillance is unknown
and costs are highly variable among health
systems. This surgical bias is absent in the
nephrological literature.
There are various and similar surveillance
regimens used for MCDK. Generally, these
include renal US every 3–6 months for the
first year, every 6 months in the second year
and then annually thereafter. The main
indication for frequent surveillance is to
detect WT. The prognosis after treating WT
depends on the stage and histology at surgery.
Children with lower stage disease (I, II) have an
excellent 4-year recurrence-free survival
(
≈
95%) compared to higher-stage disease (III,
IV;
≈
85%) for both the National WT Study
Group and the Société Internationale
d’Oncologie Pédiatrique protocols. More
important than stage is tumour histology;
children with stage I and unfavourable
histology (anaplasia) have a significantly
lower overall survival (83%) than children
with stage I and favourable histology (98%).
Although time and growth will inevitably
increase the stage, there is no evidence that
time does or does not affect histology.
There are disorders that have a well
documented association with WT, i.e.
Beckwith–Wiedmann syndrome (BWS) and
idiopathic hemihypertrophy (IHH). As WTs
grow so rapidly, experience with screening
children with BWS/IHH has shown that US is
needed every 3–4 months to effectively lower
the tumour stage [35,36]. Notably, in the
screened population, 20% of children had
false-positive results and thus had surgery for
benign lesions. Frequent surveillance is not
recommended after 6 years of age in the
BWS/IHH population. The incidence of WT in
these patients (
≈
5%) is 100 times higher than
the theoretical incidence (0.05%) of WT in
patients with MCDK.
How does the risk of WT compare with other
childhood malignancies? The incidence of
WT, brain cancer and leukaemia per million
children per year is 8, 33 and 44, respectively;
the last two cancers are significantly more
deadly. Unfortunately, there is no economic,
noninvasive manner to screen all children for
these grave cancers. As the incidence of
MCDK is only 1 in 4000, there is a small at-risk
population who can be screened. Fortunately,
US is relatively inexpensive and not invasive.
Beyond cancer screening, surveillance of
these kidneys is advantageous as some will
grow. What has not been answered is the
appropriate frequency of surveillance. If the
goal is to down-stage a WT, a 4-month
frequency until age 4 years would be
necessary.
In conclusion, the incidence of MCDK is
≈
1 in
4000 live births, of which 60% will regress or
involute within 3 years. Up to a third of
patients will have VUR into the contralateral
kidney, of which 90% is grade I–III. The risk of
UTI appears to be associated with VUR or
coexistent urological abnormalities rather
than the MCDK. The risk of hypertension is no
greater than that in the general population
and nephrectomy is usually not curative. The
overall risk of WT developing in a MCDK is
<
1
in 2000. All reported WTs were identified
before 4 years of age and seven of 10
presented as a palpable mass. There is no
reported case of WT in association with an
involuted MCDK. As such, the risk of WT
developing in an MCDK which is regressing
or involuted is substantially
<
1 in 2000,
and is probably less than the risk of
neoplasia in a normal size kidney. There
is no evidence to support an increased risk
of RCC with MCDK.
Previous reports support the non-surgical
management of MCDK. Although not
supported by firm published evidence, the
common practice has been to remove
palpable or growing MCDKs; however, such
cases are rare. The increased risk of WT
supports surveillance with US up to 4 years
old, but there is no evidence to guide the
appropriate frequency of renal imaging.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We appreciate the input and review
of this manuscript before submission by
J. Bruce Beckwith, MD. Angelo Cambio,
MD, was supported by the Aventis
Clinical Research Fellowship in Urologic
Oncology.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
None declared.
REFERENCES
1
Kuwertz-Broeking E, Brinkmann OA,
Von Lengerke HJ
et al.
Unilateral
multicystic dysplastic kidney: experience
in children.
BJU Int
2004;
93
: 388–92
2
Gordon AC, Thomas DF, Arthur RJ,
Irving HC.
Multicystic dysplastic kidney:
is nephrectomy still appropriate?
J Urol
1988;
140
: 1231–4
3
Beckwith JB.
Wilms tumor and
multicystic dysplastic kidney disease.
Editorial Comment.
J Urol
1997;
158
:
2259–60
4
Rickwood AM, Anderson PA, Williams
MP.
Multicystic renal dysplasia detected
by prenatal ultrasonography. Natural
history and results of conservative
management.
Br J Urol
1992;
69
: 538–40
5
Bloom DA, Brosman S.
The multicystic
kidney.
J Urol
1978;
120
: 211–5
6
Eckoldt F, Woderich R, Smith RD,
Heling KS.
Antenatal diagnostic aspects
of unilateral multicystic kidney dysplasia
– sensitivity, specificity, predictive values,
differential diagnoses, associated
malformations and consequences.
Fetal
Diagn Ther
2004;
19
: 163–9
7
Mandell J, Paltiel HJ, Peters CA,
Benacerraf BR.
Prenatal findings
associated with a unilateral
nonfunctioning or absent kidney.
J Urol
1994;
152
: 176–8
8
Bhide A, Sairam S, Farrugia MK, Boddy
SA, Thilaganathan B.
The sensitivity of
antenatal ultrasound for predicting renal
tract surgery in early childhood.
Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol
2005;
25
:
489–92
9
Eckoldt F, Woderich R, Wolke S, Heling
KS, Stover B, Tennstedt C.
Follow-up of
unilateral multicystic kidney dysplasia
after prenatal diagnosis.
J Matern Fetal
Neonatal Med
2003;
14
: 177–86
10
Flack CE, Bellinger MF.
The multicystic
dysplastic kidney and contralateral
vesicoureteral reflux: protection of the
solitary kidney.
J Urol
1993;
150
: 1873–4
11
Ismaili K, Avni FE, Alexander M,
Schulman C, Collier F, Hall M.
Routine
voiding cystourethrography is of no value
in neonates with unilateral multicystic
dysplastic kidney.
J Pediatr
2005;
146
:
759–63
12
Miller DC, Rumohr JA, Dunn RL, Bloom
CAMBIO
ET AL.
DA, Park JM.
What is the fate of the
refluxing contralateral kidney in children
with multicystic dysplastic kidney?
J Urol
2004;
172
: 1630–4
13
Rottenberg GT, Gordon I, De Bruyn R.
The natural history of the multicystic
dysplastic kidney in children.
Br J Radiol
1997;
70
: 347–50
14
Selzman AA, Elder JS.
Contralateral
vesicoureteral reflux in children with a
multicystic kidney.
J Urol
1995;
153
:
1252–4
15
Heymans C, Breysem L, Proesmans
W.
Multicystic kidney dysplasia: a
prospective study on the natural history
of the affected and the contralateral
kidney.
Eur J Pediatr
1998;
157
: 673–5
16
Rabelo EA, Oliveira EA, Diniz JS
et al.
Natural history of multicystic kidney
conservatively managed: a prospective
study.
Pediatr Nephrol
2004;
19
: 1102–7
17
Rabelo EA, Oliveira EA, Silva GS,
Pezzuti IL, Tatsuo ES.
Predictive factors
of ultrasonographic involution of
prenatally detected multicystic dysplastic
kidney.
BJU Int
2005;
95
: 868–71
18
Narchi H.
Risk of hypertension with
multicystic kidney disease: a systematic
review.
Arch Dis Child
2005;
90
: 921–4
19
Wacksman J, Phipps L.
Report of the
Multicystic Kidney Registry: preliminary
findings.
J Urol
1993;
150
: 1870–2
20
Husmann DA.
Renal dysplasia: the risks
and consequences of leaving dysplastic
tissue in situ.
Urology
1998;
52
: 533–6
21
de Oliveira-Filho AG, Carvalho MH,
Sbragia-Neto L, Miranda ML, Bustorff-
Silva JM, de Oliveira ER.
Wilms tumor in
a prenatally diagnosed multicystic kidney.
J Urol
1997;
158
: 1926–7
22
Minevich E, Wacksman J, Phipps L,
Lewis AG, Sheldon CA.
The Importance
of accurate diagnosis and early close
followup in patients with suspected
multicystic dysplastic kidney.
J Urol
1997;
158
: 1301–4
23
Homsy YL, Anderson JH, Oudjhane K,
Russo P.
Wilms tumor and multicystic
dysplastic kidney disease.
J Urol
1997;
158
: 2256–9
24
Oddone M, Marino C, Sergi C
et al.
Wilms’ tumor arising in a multicystic
kidney.
Pediatr Radiol
1994;
24
:
236–8
25
Dimmick JE, Johnson HW, Coleman GU,
Carter M.
Wilms tumorlet, nodular renal
blastema and multicystic renal dysplasia.
J Urol 1989; 142: 484–5
26 Hartman GE, Smolik LM, Shochat SJ.
The dilemma of the multicystic dysplastic
kidney. Am J Dis Child 1986; 140: 925–
8
27 Raffensperger J, Abousleiman A.
Abdominal masses in children under on
year of age. Surgery 1968; 63: 514–21
28 Uson AC, Del Rosario C, Melicow MM.
Wilms tumor in association with cystic
renal disease: report of two cases. J Urol
1960; 83: 262–6
29 Elder JS, Hladky D, Selzman AA.
Outpatient nephrectomy for
nonfunctioning kidneys. J Urol 1995; 154:
712–4
30 Noe HN, Marshall JH, Edwards OP.
Nodular renal blastema in the multicystic
kidney. J Urol 1989; 142: 486–8
31 Beckwith JB. The John Lattimer lecture.
Wilms tumor and other renal tumors of
childhood: an update. J Urol 1986; 136:
320–4
32 Narchi H. Risk of Wilms’ tumour with
multicystic kidney disease: a systematic
review. Arch Dis Child 2005; 90: 147–9
33 Yerkes EB, Adams MC, Pope J, Ct
Brock JW 3rd. Does every patient with
prenatal hydronephrosis need voiding
cystourethrography? J Urol 1999; 162:
1218–20
34 Anonymous National High Blood
Pressure Education Program Working
Group on High Blood Pressure in
Children and Adults. The fourth report
on the diagnosis, evaluation, and
treatment of high blood pressure in
children and adolescents. Pediatrics 2004;
114: 555–76
35 Choyke PL, Siegel MJ, Craft AW, Green
DM, DeBaun MR. Screening for Wilms
tumor in children with Beckwith–
Wiedemann syndrome or idiopathic
hemihypertrophy. Med Pediatr Oncol
1999; 32: 196–200
36 Hoyme HE, Seaver LH, Jones KL,
Procopio F, Crooks W, Feingold M.
Isolated hemihyperplasia
(hemihypertrophy): report of a
prospective multicenter study of the
incidence of neoplasia and review. Am J
Med Genet 1998; 79: 274–8
Correspondence: Eric A. Kurzrock, Department
of Urology, 4860 Y St., Suite 3500,
Sacramento, CA 95817, USA.
e-mail:
<script language='JavaScript' type='text/javascript'>
<!--
var prefix = 'ma' + 'il' + 'to';
var path = 'hr' + 'ef' + '=';
var addy61575 = 'eric.kurzrock' + '@';
addy61575 = addy61575 + 'ucdmc' + '.' + 'ucdavis' + '.' + 'edu';
document.write( '<a ' + path + '\'' + prefix + ':' + addy61575 + '\'>' );
document.write( addy61575 );
document.write( '<\/a>' );
//-->\n </script><script language='JavaScript' type='text/javascript'>
<!--
document.write( '<span style=\'display: none;\'>' );
//-->
</script>This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it
<script language='JavaScript' type='text/javascript'>
<!--
document.write( '</' );
document.write( 'span>' );
//-->
</script>
Abbreviations: MCDK, multicystic dysplastic
kidney; US, ultrasonography; VCUG, voiding
cysto-urethrography; WT, Wilms’ tumour;
BWS, Beckwith–Wiedmann syndrome; IHH,
idiopathic hemihypertrophy.](http://urotoday.com/images/stories/bjui_april2008cover.jpg)

